Theology Thursdays: Confessing Christ in a World of Violence
Sojourners is a Christian ministry whose mission is to proclaim and practice the Biblical call to integrate spiritual renewal and social justice. The following statement was endorsed by more than 200 Christian theologians and ethicists. It appears on the Sojourners website.
Our world is wracked with violence and war. But Jesus said: "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God" (Matt. 5:9). Innocent people, at home and abroad, are increasingly threatened by terrorist attacks. But Jesus said: "Love your enemies, pray for those who persecute you" (Matt. 5:44). These words, which have never been easy, seem all the more difficult today.
Nevertheless, a time comes when silence is betrayal. How many churches have heard sermons on these texts since the terrorist atrocities of September 11? Where is the serious debate about what it means to confess Christ in a world of violence? Does Christian "realism" mean resigning ourselves to an endless future of "pre-emptive wars"? Does it mean turning a blind eye to torture and massive civilian casualties? Does it mean acting out of fear and resentment rather than intelligence and restraint?
Faithfully confessing Christ is the church's task, and never more so than when its confession is co-opted by militarism and nationalism.
- A "theology of war," emanating from the highest circles of American government, is seeping into our churches as well.
- The language of "righteous empire" is employed with growing frequency.
- The roles of God, church, and nation are confused by talk of an American "mission" and "divine appointment" to "rid the world of evil."
The security issues before our nation allow no easy solutions. No one has a monopoly on the truth. But a policy that rejects the wisdom of international consultation should not be baptized by religiosity. The danger today is political idolatry exacerbated by the politics of fear.
In this time of crisis, we need a new confession of Christ.
1. Jesus Christ, as attested in Holy Scripture, knows no national boundaries. Those who confess his name are found throughout the earth. Our allegiance to Christ takes priority over national identity. Whenever Christianity compromises with empire, the gospel of Christ is discredited.
We reject the false teaching that any nation-state can ever be described with the words, "the light shines in the darkness and the darkness has not overcome it." These words, used in scripture, apply only to Christ. No political or religious leader has the right to twist them in the service of war.
2. Christ commits Christians to a strong presumption against war. The wanton destructiveness of modern warfare strengthens this obligation. Standing in the shadow of the Cross, Christians have a responsibility to count the cost, speak out for the victims, and explore every alternative before a nation goes to war. We are committed to international cooperation rather than unilateral policies.
We reject the false teaching that a war on terrorism takes precedence over ethical and legal norms. Some things ought never be done - torture, the deliberate bombing of civilians, the use of indiscriminate weapons of mass destruction - regardless of the consequences.
3. Christ commands us to see not only the splinter in our adversary's eye, but also the beam in our own. The distinction between good and evil does not run between one nation and another, or one group and another. It runs straight through every human heart.
We reject the false teaching that America is a "Christian nation," representing only virtue, while its adversaries are nothing but vicious. We reject the belief that America has nothing to repent of, even as we reject that it represents most of the world's evil. All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God (Rom 3:23).
4. Christ shows us that enemy-love is the heart of the gospel. While we were yet enemies, Christ died for us (Rom. 5:8, 10). We are to show love to our enemies even as we believe God in Christ has shown love to us and the whole world. Enemy-love does not mean capitulating to hostile agendas or domination. It does mean refusing to demonize any human being created in God's image.
We reject the false teaching that any human being can be defined as outside the law's protection. We reject the demonization of perceived enemies, which only paves the way to abuse; and we reject the mistreatment of prisoners, regardless of supposed benefits to their captors.
5. Christ teaches us that humility is the virtue befitting forgiven sinners. It tempers all political disagreements, and it allows that our own political perceptions, in a complex world, may be wrong.
We reject the false teaching that those who are not for the United States politically are against it or that those who fundamentally question American policies must be with the "evil-doers." Such crude distinctions, especially when used by Christians, are expressions of the Manichaean heresy, in which the world is divided into forces of absolute good and absolute evil.
The Lord Jesus Christ is either authoritative for Christians, or he is not. His Lordship cannot be set aside by any earthly power. His words may not be distorted for propagandistic purposes. No nation-state may usurp the place of God.
We believe that acknowledging these truths is indispensable for followers of Christ. We urge them to remember these principles in making their decisions as citizens. Peacemaking is central to our vocation in a troubled world where Christ is Lord.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Signers as of October 22, 2004. Institutions for identification only.
Name Organization Title Adam, A.K.M. Seabury-Western Theological Seminary Professor of New Testament Alexander, Dr. Paul Pentecostal Peace Fellowship/Southwestern Assemblies of God University President/Associate Professor of Bible and Theology Amerson, Philip Claremont School of Theology President Arichea, Jr, Daniel C. Duke Divinity School and UMC Bishop in Residence Arnold, Johann Christoph, Sr. The Bruderhof Elder Augsburger, David Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Pastoral Care and Counseling Augsburger, Dr. Myron S. Eastern Mennonite University President Emeritus Bader-Saye, Scott University of Scranton Associate Professor of Theology and Ethics Baker, Mark D. Mennonite Brethren Biblical Seminary Assistant professor of Mission and Theology Balch, David Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University Professor of New Testament Balmer, Randall Barnard College, Columbia University Ann Whitney Olin Professor of American Religion Balswick, Jack Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Sociology and Family Development Barrett, Lois Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Director, Great Plains Extension Bartlett, Dr. Anthony W. Wood Hath Hope Bible Community Founder Batastini, Robert J. GIA Publications Senior Editor Batstone, David University of San Francisco Professor of Ethics Battle, Rev. Michael, PhD Duke University Professor and Episcopal Priest Beach-Verhey, Timothy Davidson College Director of Programs for the Theological Exploration of Vocation Bezilla, Rev. Gregory The Episcopal Campus Ministry at Rutgers Chaplain Black, Clifton Princeton Theological Seminary Professor of Biblical Theology Bonk, Dr. Jonathan J. Overseas Ministry Study Center Executive Director Borgman, Paul Gordon College Professor Bouma-Prediger, Dr. Steven Hope College Jacobson Professor of Religion Branson, Mark Lau Fuller Theological Seminary Associate Professor Brawley, Robert L. McCormick Theological Seminary Albert C. McGaw Professor of New Testament Brock, Brian University of Aberdeen Lecturer in Practical Theology Brown, Colin Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Systematic Theology Brubacher, Ray Mennonite World Conference Associate Executive Secretary for Events and Administration Bruner, Frederick Fuller Theological Seminary Adjunct Faculty Brunk, III, George R. Eastern Mennonite Seminary Professor of New Testament Buckley, Jim Loyola College Professor of Theology Bullon, Dr. H. Fernando Latin American Theological Fraternity—Costa Rica Chapter President Burnette, Carole C., PhD Ecumenical Institute of Theology Professor of Ancient and Medieval Christianity Butler, Dr. Anthea Loyola Marymount University President, Society for Pentecostal Studies and Assistant Professor of Theology Butler, James Fuller Theological Seminary Associate Professor of Old Testament Campbell, Douglas A. Duke Divinity School Assistant Professor in New Testament Campolo, Tony Eastern University Professor of Sociology Candler, The Very Rev. Samuel G. Dean of the Cathedral The Cathedral of St. Philip Carmer, Gregory W. Gordon College Dean of the Chapel Casey, Shaun Wesley Theological Seminary Assistant Professor of Christian Ethics Chancey, Mark A. Southern Methodist University Assistant Professor of Religious Studies Chapman, Stephen Duke Divinity School Ass. Prof. Old Testament Chittister, Joan, OSB Benetvision Writer Clark, Chapman Fuller Theological Seminary Associate Professor of Youth, Family, and Culture Copan, Victor, Th.D. Palm Beach Atlantic University’s School of Ministry Associate Professor of Ministry Crane, Richard Messiah College Professor Crenshaw, James L. Duke Divinity School Professor of Old Testament Davis, Derek H. Baylor University Director, J.M. Dawson Institute of Church-State Studies Davis, Ellen F. Duke Divinity School Professor of Bible and Practical Theology Davis, Dr. Lant B. Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary Assistant to the President De La Torre, Dr. Miguel A. Hope College Professor of Religion DeCrane, Susanne M., PhD College of Notre Dame of Maryland Associate Faculty Dewey, Brett R. Baylor University Teaching Fellow Donahue, Prof. John R., SJ St. Mary’s Seminary and University Raymond E. Brown Professor Emeritus of New Testament Studies Dorn, Jacob H. Wright State University Dueck, Dr. Alvin Fuller Theological Seminary Evelyn and Frank Freed Professor of the Integration of Psychology and Theology Dunn, Rev. Dr. James M. Wake Forest Univ. Divinity School Professor of Christianity and Public Policy Eastman, Rev. Dr. Susan Grove Duke Divinity School Assistant Professor of the Practice of Bible and Christian Formation Elwood, Christopher Louisville Pres. Theo. Seminary Professor of Historical Theology Epp, Robert C. UCLA Professor Emeritus Erdman, Chris The Biblical Seminary Professor of Preaching and Missional Leadership Esbenshade, Wade Penn State University Researcher Evans, C. Stephen Baylor University Prof. Philosophy and Humanities Fackre, Gabriel Andover Newton Theological School Abbot Professor of Christian Theology Emeritus Faramelli, Norman Boston University School of Theology Lecturer in Social Ethics Ferree-Clark, Rev. Nancy Duke University Chapel Pastor Fisher, Mary Elizabeth Asbury Theological Seminary Formerly Ass’t. Professor of Biblical Theology Fisk, Bruce N. Westmont College Ass. Prof. Religious Studies Fletcher, Andy International Communities Foundation Executive Director Fowl, Stephen Loyola College in Maryland Professor of Theology Fredrickson, Kurt Fuller Theological Seminary Assistant Professor Freeman, Curtis W. Duke Divinity School Professor of Theology and Baptist Studies Fretheim, Terence Luther Seminary Elva B. Lovell Professor of Old Testament Friesen, Dr. John J. Canadian Mennonite University Professor of History and Theology Fulkerson, Rev. Dr. Mary McClintock Duke University (Divinity School) Associate Professor of Theology Garrettson, Dr. Charles The Hill School Educator Geddert, Dr. Timothy J. Mennonite Brethren Biblical Seminary Associate Professor of New Testament George, Ivy Gordon College Professor Gill, David W. Ethixbiz.com Writer Gloer, W. Huitt Baylor University Professor of Preaching Goering, Lisa M. North Carolina State University Post-Doctoral Fellow Gorman, Michael J. St. Mary’s Seminary and University Dean and Professor of New Testament Gouwens, David J. Brite Divinity School, Texas Christian University Interim Dean and Professor of Theology Grieb, Rev. Dr. A. Katherine Virginia Theological Seminary Associate Professor of New Testament Guenther, Dr. Titus Canadian Mennonite University Associate Professor of Theology and Missions Gutenson, Charles E. Asbury Theological Seminary Associate Professor of Philosophical Theology and Associate Dean for Distributed Learning Hagner, Donald Fuller Theological Seminary George Eldon Ladd Professor of New Testament Hall, Rev. Dr. Amy Laura Duke Divinity School/SW Texas UMC Assistant Professor of Theological Ethics Harrison, Nina St. Vincent de Paul Society Executive Director Harvard, Susan The Hill School Educator Harvey, Barry Baylor University Associate Professor of Theology Hart, John Boston University School of Theology Professor of Christian Ethics Hauerwas, Stanley Duke Divinity School Prof. Theological Ethics Hawkins, Peter S. Boston University Prof. Religion Hays, Richard Duke Divinity School Prof. New Testament Henderson, Susan Watts, PhD Salem College Assistant Professor of Religion Henrich, Sarah S. Luther Seminary Assoc. Prof. New Testament Hess, Mary E. Luther Seminary Assistant Professor of Educational Leadership Heun, Dr. Matthew Calvin College Professor Hinkle, Mary E. Luther Seminary Assoc. Prof. New Testament Hinrichs, Andrew T. University of New Mexico MBA student/Wheaton alum 2000 Hollar, Barry Penn Shenandoah University Professor of Religion Holleman, Connie United Church of Christ Holleman, Toby UCC Penn Northeast Conference Associate Conference Minister Holloway, Jeph East Texas Baptist University Assoc. Prof. Theology and Ethics Hough, Jr., Joseph C. Union Theological Seminary President of the Faculty and William E. Dodge Professor of Social Ethics Hughes, Richard T. Pepperdine University Distinguished Professor of Religion Hunsinger, Deborah van Deusen Princeton Theological Seminary Associate Professor of Pastoral Theology Hunsinger, George Princeton Theological Seminary Professor of Systematic Theology Hunter, George Asbury Theological Seminary Distinguished Professor of Evangelization Hurley, Elizabeth Lancaster Literary Guild Director Hurst, Brenda Martin Eastern Mennonite Seminary Assistant Professor of Practical Theology Hutson, Christopher R. Hood Theological Seminary Associate Professor of New Testament Isaak, Jon Mark Mennonite Brethren Biblical Seminary Associate Professor of New Testament Japinga, Dr. Lynn Hope College Associate Professor of Religion Johnson, Dr. William Stacy Princeton Theological Seminary Assoc. Prof. Systematic Theology Johnson, Rev. Janeen Bertsche Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Campus Pastor Johnson, Robert E. Central Baptist Theological Seminary Assoc. Prof. Church Hist. & Miss. Johnston, Dr. Robert Fuller Theological Seminary face="Arial">Professor of Theology and Culture Jordan, Rev. Laurel Macaulay Middlebury College Chaplain of the College Keller, Dr. Catherine Drew University, The Theological School Professor of Constructive Theology Kenneson, Philip D. Milligan College Associate Professor of Theology and Philosophy Kernaghan, Ron Fuller Theological Seminary Director of Office of Presbyterian Ministries Klassen, Joane Recovery of Hope Counseling Director Kolden, Marc Luther Seminary Professor of Systematic Theology Koontz, Gayle Gerber Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Professor of Theology and Ethics Koontz, Ted Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Professor of Ethics and Peace Studies Kraus, C. Norman Goshen College Prof. Emeritus Kraybill, J. Nelson Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary President Kreider, Alan Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Associate Professor of Church History and Mission Kuperus, Tracy, PhD Calvin College Adjunct Professor of Political Science La Barge, Karen Fitz WITNESS Executive Director Lancaster, Sarah Heaner Methodist Theological School in Ohio Associate Professor of Theology, Bishop Hazen G. Werner Chair Lanci, Dr. John R. Stonehill College Associate Professor of Religious Studies Langan, John SJ Georgetown University Joseph Cardinal Bernardin Professor of Catholic Social Thought Lapsley, Jacqueline Princeton Theological Seminary Associate Professor of Old Testament Laytham, D. Brent North Park Theological Seminary Associate Professor of Theology and Ethics Leith, Mary Joan Winn Stonehill College Associate Professor of Religious Studies Leonard, Dr. Bill Wake Forest University Dean of the Divinity School and Professor of Church History Lesniewski, Jacob Mennonite Central Committee Community Development Worker Lesniewski, Sarah Mennonite Central Committee Community Development Worker Lowe, Walter Emory University (Candler School) Professor of Systematic Theology Lundblad, Barbara K. Union Theological Seminary Joe R. Engle Associate Professor of Preaching Lyden, John Dana College Professor and Chair of Religion Malcolm, Lois Luther Seminary Associate Professor of Systematic Theology Martens, Elmer Mennonite Brethren Biblical Seminary Professor Emeritus of Old Testament Martinez, Juan Fuller Seminary Director of Hispanic Church Studies Program McFague, Dr. Sallie Vancouver School of Theology, Vancouver, BC Distinguished Theologian in Residence McFarland, Ian A. University of Aberdeen Senior Lecturer in Systematic Theology McGarvey, Rev. Will Community Presbyterian Church Pastor McGoldrick, Doug Columbia College, Chicago Part Time Faculty McKelway, Alexander J. Davidson College Paul B. Freeland Professor of Religion Emeritus McLaren, Brian Mars Hill Graduate School Adjunct Professor Middleton, J. Richard Roberts Wesleyan College Associate Professor of Biblical Studies Mikoski, Gordon S. Princeton Theological Seminary Instructor in Christian Education Miller, Charles William University of North Dakota Associate Professor and Chair of Department of Philosophy and Religion Miller, Patrick D. Princeton Theological Seminary Professor of Old Testament Theology Moore-Keish, Martha Columbia Theological Seminary Assistant Professor of Theology Moulder, Wiliam J. Trinity College Professor of New Testament Murphy, Nancey Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Christian Philosophy Mustol, John S. Bethel Seminary San Diego Teaching Assistant Nash, James A. Professor of Christian Ethics, Retired Nordling, Cherith Fee Calvin College Adjunct Professor of Systematic Theology O’Brien, J. Randall Baylor University Professor and Chair, Dept. of Religion Ollenburger, Bob,PhD Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Professor of Biblical Olson, Dennis Princeton Theological Seminary Professor of Old Testament Olson, Roger E. Baylor University Prof. Theology Osmer, Rick Princeton Theological Seminary Padgett, Alan G. Luther Seminary Prof. Systematic Theology Padilla, Catherine F. Kairos Foundation Professor of Bible Padilla, Rene Kairos Foundation President Emeritus Padilla DeBorst, Ruth Latin American Theological Fraternity President Pallmeyer, Paul H. Evangelical Lutheran Church in America Retired Director for Evangelism for the ALC Pasquarello, Dr. Michael Asbury Theological Seminary Ass. Prof. Practical Theology Paul, Rev. Dr. Arthur Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Ass. Prof. Pastor Theology Payne, John B. Lancaster Theological Seminary Professor Emeritus of Church History Peace, Richard Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Evangelism and Spiritual Formation Peterson, Dr. Rodney L. Boston Theological Institute Executive Director Phelan, John E., Jr. North Park Theological Seminary President and Dean Pierard, Dr. Richard V. Gordon College Stephen Phillips Professor of History Placher, William C. Wabash College LaFollette Distinguished Professor in the Humanities Powell, Jeff Duke Law and Divinity Schools Professor of Divinity Prescott, Dr. Bruce Mainstream Oklahoma Baptists Executive Director Racine-Jones, Kathryn Notre Dame de Namur University Campus Minister Ramsey, Janet Luther Seminary Assoc. Prof. Congregational Care Leadership Redekopp, Alf Mennonite Heritage Center Director Reese, Dr. Boyd T. Eastern Mennonite University Director of Libraries Reid, David W. Vital Theology Publisher Rempel, John D. Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Ass. Prof. Historical Theology Rensberger, David Interdenominational Theological Center Prof. New Testament Riswold, Caryn Illinois Colege Assistant Professor of Religion Rivera-Pagán, Luís N. Princeton Theological Seminary Henry Winters Luce Professor of Ecumenics Roberts, Rev. Dr. Raymond R. Grace Presbyterian Church Pastor Robinson, Elaine A. Brite Divinity School Assistant Professor or Theology and Methodist Studies Rodriguez, Rev. Dr. Daniel R. McCormick Theological Seminary Professor Emeritus of Church History Rogers, Eugene F., Jr. University of Virginia Associate Professor Russell, Rev. Dr. Horace O. Eastern Baptist Theological Seminary Professor of Historical Theology (Ret.) Rutledge, Rev. Fleming Pastor Sadler, Dr. Rodney S., Jr. Union—PSCE at Charlotte Assistant Professor of Bible Sanders, Cheryl J. Howard University Professor of Christian Ethics Sawyer, James R. Jim Elliot School Lead Teacher / Ass’t. Administrator Schmitz, Gladys School Sisters of Notre Dame, Mankato SSND Schofield-Bodt, Rev. Dr. Brian Golden Hill United Methodist Church Pastor Scholer, David Professor of New Testament Scorgie,Dr. Glen G. Bethel Seminary San Diego Professor of Theology Scott, Dr. Lindy Wheaton College Associate Professor of Spanish Shank, David A. Mennonite Mission Network Shank, Wilma Mennonite Mission Network Shirley, Dr. Edward L. St. Edward’s University Department of Religious Studies Shuman, Joel James King’s College Department of Theology Shurden, Walter B. Mercer University Professor of Christianity and Executive Director of the Ctr. For Baptist Studies Shuster, Marguerite Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Preaching Simmons, Morgan Garrett/Evangelical Seminary Retired Professor Singletary, Rev. Dr. Jon E., MSW Baylor University School of Social Work Assistant Professor Slessarev-Jamir, Helene Wheaton College Associate Professor of Politics and International Relations/Dir. Of Urban Studies Smith, Dr. Robin Victorville Church of the Nazarene Senior Pastor Sniegocki, John Xavier University Professor of Theology Snodgras, Prof. Klyne North Park Theological Seminary Paul W. Brandel Professor of New Testament Soards, Marion L. Louisville Presbyterian Theol. Sem. Professor of New Testament Studies Sonderegger, Katherine Virginia Theological Seminary Professor Stam, Doris Latin America Mission Stam, Juan Latin American Mission & Nat’l. Univ. of Costa Rica Stassen, Glen Fuller Theological Seminary Professor of Christian Ethics Stauffer, Michael Wheaton College Associate Professor Stubbs, David Western Theological Seminary Assistant Professor of Ethics and Theology Swartley, Willard M. Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Prof. New Testament (Emeritus) Swartzenruber, Dr. Elaine K. Wake Forest University Ass. Prof. Religion – Theology and Culture Tankerlsey, Bruce East Texas Baptist University Taylor, Mark Princeton Theological Seminary Prof. Theology and Culture Teig, Dr. Mons A. Luther Seminary Professor of Worship Thiemann, Ronald F. Harvard Divinity School Professor of Theology and Religion and Society Thistlethwaite, Dr. Susan Chicago Theological Seminary President and Professor of Theology Tobin, Mary Lynn David Community Church (PCUSA) Pastor Tull, Rev. Dr. Patricia K. Louisville Presbyterian Seminary Professor of Old Testament Utz, John Duke Divinity School Visiting Assistant Prof. of Lit. and Theology Van Leeuwen, Raymond C. Eastern University Professor of Biblical Studies Van Dyk, Dr. Leanne Western Theological Seminary Dean & Prof. Reformed Theology van Huyssteen, J. Wentzel Princeton Theological Seminary James I. McCrod Professor of Theology and Science Verhey, Dr. Allen Duke Divinity School Professor of Christian Ethics Volf, Dr. Miroslav Yale University Henry B. Wright Professor of Systematic Theology and Director of Yale Center for Faith and Culture Voth, Dr. Esteban United Bible Societies Translation Consultant Wagener, Linda Fuller Theological Seminary SOP Assistant Dean Wagner, Don North Park University, Chicago Professor Wagner, J. Ross Princeton Theological Seminary Associate Professor of New Testament Wallis, Jim Sojourners Editor Weaver, Dorothy Jean Eastern Mennonite Seminary Professor of New Testament West, Dr. Cornel Princeton University Professor of Religion Westermeyer, Paul Luther Seminary Professor of Church Music Wheeler, Sondra Wesley Theological Seminary Martha Ashby Carr Professor of Christian Ethics Williams, Clifford Trinity College Professor of Philosophy Williams, Dr. David Alan Taylor University College Academic Vice President, Professor of Philosophical Theology and Ethics Willimon, Will Duke University Former Dean of the Chapel and Professor of Christian Ministry at Duke University Wink, Johnny Ouachita Baptist University Professor Wirzba, Norman Georgetown College Chair of Philosophy Witherington, Dr. Ben Asbury Theological Seminary Professor of New Testament Wood, Ralph C. Baylor University University Professor of Theology and Literature Wylie-Kellerman, Bill S.C.U.P.E. Director of Graduate Theological Urban Studies Yoder, Dr. Nathan E. Eastern Mennonite Seminary Associate Professor of Church History Yoder, Perry Assoc. Mennonite Biblical Seminary Prof. Old Testament
Thursday, November 4, 2004 To discuss this article further enter The Deeper Look Dialogue Room
The views and opinions expressed herein by the author do not necessarily represent the opinions or position of BlackElectorate.com or Black Electorate Communications.
|